Saturday, March 8, 2008

I am watching The Doha Debates on BBC right now. This week the debate is on the motion 'muslims aroud the world are not doing enough to curb extremism'. A lot of intelligence noise is being made. There is Daisy Khan speaking against the motion. She feels that the media is only concentrating on the radical muslims around the world, but on the other hand there are many muslims, majority of muslims , who condemn violence and protest against it, but these vioces are not heard.
A guy in the audience put up a question as to what America is doing to combat extremism, Iftiqar who is speaking for the motion responded that what America is doing is electing the new President in 2009, and the person would not be George W. Bush. While the sentiment is applaudable, my concern is that Iraqi occupation happened before the last election and George W. Bush was reelected.
I can relate to this being an Indian, where I can cite a similar example from our Gujarat experience. Despite the failure of the BJP government in Gujarat to prevent the mass killings post Godhra, the Narendra Modi led govt came back into power, and convincingly. It was a disappointment which I have not been able to do away with despite the economic progress of Gujarat in the last few years.
So whose responsibility is it? Extremism of anykind is unacceptable, no matter who the perpetrator. But can we put an entire civilisation in a corner and expect them to apologise for what a few members of their community are doing in the name of their religion? I dont know the answers to these questions. I am not a muslim and I dont know how it feels to be put under the lens all the time, to be suspected and to be expected to make loud noises in order to prove that I am not on the side of the bad guys.
I feel that the world is becoming more and more intolerant and wary. But also that all is not lost. We can still make a change if we want to. Somebody said that we need to get our house in order before we start criticising others for what we perceive as the wrongs they are doing to us. So we all need to introspect, think over what we are doing and whether it is enough. It is never enough until the problem is solved. So lets try to solve it by cleaning up our houses.

Friday, February 29, 2008

Truth about Palestine?

For a long time now, I have wondered about the Israeli- Palestine situation. Or should I call it a mess. Now a report of UN commission of Human Rights (Prof. Dugard's report), suggests what we have long known to be the truth. The report says that Palestinian 'terrorism' is the inevitable though painful consequence of Israeli occupation of Palestinian territories. Prof Dugard, who was once at the centre of South African struggle against apartheid has termed Palestinian terrorism as deplorable, yet inevitable.
Why Palestine? A land so torn apart by those who were responsible for its governance. One cannot but feel frustrated that the British Mandate went so wrong that instead of leaving the mandated territory of Palestine as a self respecting state, they decided to tear it apart and offer chunks of it to Jews scattered all over Europe as some sort of expiation from what happened in Nazi Germany.
Now the Israelis threaten the Palestinians living in the Gaza strip with an even bigger holocaust. Agreed acts of violence against innocent civilians are deplorable no matter what the motivation behind them. To that extent one has to condemn the acts of terrorism against the Israelis . However the Israeli people can no longer escape their responsibility under the international law or their moral responsibility towards the Palestinians. You cannot forcibly enter into someone's house, throw them into their own backyard, and then make their lives miserable in that backyard also and then expect them to be polite...
Palestinians have lost their basic civil rights, they have lost their most important political right- their right to statehood. They have been relegated to the status of stateless people, while foreigners have come into their lands, made homes out of them, established government and international relations, become a part of the United Nations, and won the right to decry loudly and violently 'Palestinian acts of terrorism'. In all this Israel has very conveniently forgotten that the creation of Israel was through such unspeakable acts of terrorism, which led to the Palestinian exodus from what we now call Israel, but what should have been Palestine.
As far as the biblical references to Israel are concerned any biblical scholar will tell us that the Israelis never consistently occupied Palestine, that the earliest known inhabitants of Palestine were the Canaanites, and that the earliest known Hebrew occupation of Israel was a result of a bloody war between the Canaanites and the Jews, and that the Jewish were not the majority religion of Palestine for at least 19 centuries before the WWII, immediately after which the state of Israel was created.
The creation of Israel and the ouster of millions of Palestinians was one of the cruelest jokes of the last century, one that will continue to haunt mankind for years to come.